I've been involved in online trading, specifically with stock and index options, for several years. In this time, I've spent a great deal of time thinking about value and the fact that anything, be it a stock or currency or even a house, is worth exactly whatever someone else will pay for it. Sure, there are a million and one pricing models (especially in financial markets) that will tell you precisely what something should be worth. But in the final analysis, if nobody will pay that much, then it's not actually worth that price.
Let's illustrate this concept in a very simple fashion. I'm an American so I'll
use U.S. currency to make my point.
What is a $20 bill worth? Without over thinking it and talking about inflation,
exchange rates, etc. let's just say that it is generally believed to be worth
Would you pay me $20 for a $20 bill? I'm going to guess probably not, as there
would be no real reason to do so. You would have to go to the trouble of
getting me your $20 and I would have to go to the trouble of giving you my $20
bill, and neither of us would be in a better position than we were before.
Therefore, I would like to present the idea that a $20 bill is not actually
worth $20 since nobody would likely pay $20 for it!
So how much would you pay for a $20 bill? Would you pay $19.99? Is it worth
the effort for 1 cent? No? How about $19.50? $19? Shall I keep going?
In a free and fair market it is the market itself which determines value, and
given a large enough market, that value should be fairly accurate. I read an
article online some time ago about someone who decided to conduct an experiment
just for fun. He put a new $5 bill up for auction online and began the biding
at 1 cent. He crafted a creative description of the note, and waited to see the
results. When it was all said and done, the bill did in fact sell - for
slightly over $3. He then spoke with the winning bidder, who said he had made a
profit many times online by purchasing currency for less than face value
(including a $20 bill for less than $10 as I recall).
The conductor of the experiment left it at that - nothing more than a somewhat
humorous exploration into what people think something is worth. But to me this
meant so much more.
A dollar is not actually worth a dollar... so what is it worth? What
would you trade for $1? For $20? For $100? $1,000? And if a dollar isn't
actually worth a dollar, is a share of stock worth $50, or in fact anything at
The answer is yes. At any given moment it is worth precisely what someone is
willing to pay for it. No more, no less. Money and value are merely ideas,
they are not absolutes.
Consider this carefully the next time you are convinced that the stock, option,
currency, house, or anything else you want to buy, is worth what you're about to
Jonathan van Clute is a full time investor, educator, speaker, and online
options and sports arbitrage trader. In addition to his business activities, he
is also a musician, video editor/animator, and one of the world's greatest
Segway Polo athletes. He can be reached via email at jonathan@PMLinvestments.com
and is speaking at an upcoming teleseminar, visit
http://www.snurl.com/vcfmv for details.